DC Studios’ latest release, "Clayface," directed by James Watkins, premiered with preview screenings on Thursday ahead of its nationwide theatrical launch on Friday. The R-rated horror thriller follows Matt Hagen, portrayed by Tom Rhys Harries, as he ascends from a troubled street kid in Gotham to Hollywood fame, only to face disfigurement by a crime boss. Seeking a cure, Hagen turns to scientist Caitlyn Corr, played by Naomi Ackie, whose experimental treatment triggers monstrous side effects that propel him towards revenge. "Clayface" is the third film from James Gunn and Peter Safran’s DC Universe, following 2025’s "Superman" and 2026’s "Supergirl."

The film’s reception among critics, based on 83 reviews on Rotten Tomatoes as of October 21, 2026, stands at a 75% “fresh” score, reflecting mostly positive sentiment. This places "Clayface" between the more favored 83% rating for "Superman" and the lower 52% score for "Supergirl." Critics praised its genre-driven and horror elements, with some noting its fresh take on a lesser-known comic book character while acknowledging its darker thematic ambitions. However, a subset of reviewers found fault with the movie’s uneven tone, character motivations, and lack of self-awareness.

Positive reviews highlighted "Clayface" as an engaging monster movie with straightforward entertainment value. William Bibbiani of The Wrap and Guy Lodge of Variety appreciated its blend of horror and comic book storytelling, emphasizing its immersive and enjoyable genre mix. Peter Gray from The AU Review commended the film’s uncompromising dark approach, seeing it as a confident step for DC Studios. Meanwhile, Glen Garner from Deadline Hollywood suggested the movie could serve as a blueprint for future projects within the DC Universe.

Conversely, critics like Kate Erbland of IndieWire and Barry Hertz from Globe and Mail offered negative feedback, citing the film’s inconsistent narrative and perceived derivative nature. David Fear from Rolling Stone described it as bland, and Brian Truitt of USA Today criticized the lack of character development despite the unsettling atmosphere. Despite mixed individual opinions, the overall critical consensus leans favorable, marking "Clayface" as a promising, if imperfect, addition to the DCU’s theatrical slate.