The third season of Amazon’s “The Rings of Power” premiered this week with four episodes released on Prime Video. Although the season currently holds a "Fresh" rating on Rotten Tomatoes, its score at 71% is a noticeable drop compared to the previous seasons. While Season 1 had an 84% score from 487 reviews and Season 2 maintained an 85% rating from 173 reviews, Season 3’s rating comes from a much smaller sample of just 21 reviews so far. Audience scores for this season haven’t been posted yet, but viewership has been declining steadily since the show’s debut.
The first two seasons had mixed reception among viewers, with Season 1 receiving only a 38% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes despite a high critic rating. Season 2 saw a smaller but still marked drop, with a 58% audience score from over 5,000 user reviews. The decrease in viewers mostly reflected fans who stopped watching after the first season, leaving a more positive but narrower fanbase to rate the show in Season 2. Season 3 is expected to retain even fewer viewers, which could push the audience score higher since it’ll largely reflect opinions from dedicated fans who enjoy the series.
Critics including Forbes contributor Erik Kain have expressed skepticism about the new season, citing its lack of compelling storytelling despite impressive visuals and special effects. Kain noted a positive change with the absence of the widely criticized Harfoots storyline, but otherwise found the season’s narrative uninspired and repetitive. He argued that while early critical support for the show might have been influenced by cultural debates around its diverse casting, that goodwill has waned as the series fails to deliver quality fantasy entertainment or a faithful Tolkien adaptation.
Though some new reviews have nudged the Rotten Tomatoes critic rating to 74%, there is a general consensus that the show is struggling creatively and losing momentum. The drop in critic attention and falling viewer numbers signal that “The Rings of Power” Season 3 is having a tough time maintaining its initial buzz and audience enthusiasm. The coming weeks and the release of all episodes will show whether the series can recover or if it continues to falter with critics and fans alike.
Start the discussion with a take, question, or market read.