The article critiques the current College Football Playoff (CFP) system, highlighting its departure from earlier, more objective methods for selecting national champions, such as polls, computer rankings, and strength of schedule evaluations. It contrasts the era before 2014, when systems like the Bowl Championship Series balanced various data points with common sense, against today’s CFP committee decisions that generate billions in TV revenue but introduce baffling subjectivity. Notre Dame’s 2026 rankings exemplify these issues: after a close loss to BYU and a win over Miami, the Irish were initially ranked 11th, then suddenly jumped to fifth, despite possessing a stronger strength of schedule than undefeated teams like Utah and UCLA that rank higher.
The piece emphasizes the controversial nature of Notre Dame’s CFP treatment, particularly in a season where the team’s performance metrics were among the nation’s best. An early loss to BYU, marred by questionable officiating, was harshly penalized by the CFP committee, which ranked Notre Dame well below the Associated Press and coaches polls. Following their victory over Miami, the team’s leap to fifth spot was justified by CFP committee chair Hunter Yurachek, who cited performance dominance and losses by teams ahead of Notre Dame. Still, the disconnect between CFP rankings and objective data like strength of schedule leaves questions about the committee's criteria and consistency.
Financial motivations underpin the evolution of the CFP system, highlighted by a recent $1.7 billion ESPN television deal adding to an existing $7.8 billion contract extending through 2031. This revenue inflow has driven playoff expansion, growing from a four-team field in 2014 to 12 teams next season, then 24, with predictions of eventual expansion to 32 or even 64 teams. However, this growth increases the subjective power of the committee, as most of the expanded field’s spots will be chosen by humans rather than automatic qualification, risking further controversy and undermining the idea of deciding championships purely on field performance.
The author recalls his past opposition to a playoff system, advocating for retention of the previous hybrid approach involving polls, computers, and strength of schedule to fairly crown champions. The article warns that unchecked CFP expansion will dilute on-field outcomes, inviting greater subjectivity and potential bias. The Notre Dame rankings mess exemplifies these concerns vividly, illustrating how financial interests and committee discretion have transformed college football championship selection into a far cry from the “good old days” when more transparent and balanced methods prevailed.
Start the discussion with a take, question, or market read.