Deshaun Watson’s appointment as the Cleveland Browns’ starting quarterback has sparked an unprecedented unity among the notoriously divided Cleveland fan base—though not in favor of Watson. The Browns announced their decision to start Watson despite his poor preseason performance and his public criticism of fans following boos during a game against the Bills. This consensus against Watson is striking in a city where fan opinion is usually fragmented, especially regarding quarterbacks. Local radio host Anthony Lima highlighted that no other player in recent memory has united fans so thoroughly in opposition.

The backlash is amplified by Watson’s controversial history, which includes more than 20 civil lawsuits alleging sexual misconduct, a $230 million fully guaranteed contract, and an 11-game suspension. These off-field issues have left many Browns supporters conflicted or entirely disillusioned with the team’s decision to invest heavily in Watson. While some initially gave him a chance, his decline on the field and continued controversies have intensified fan frustration. In fact, his injuries and lackluster play have led some fans to openly cheer against him and question the organization’s commitment to the fan base.

The Browns ownership situation adds another layer of discontent. Since Jimmy Haslam bought the team in 2012, the franchise has experienced a revolving door of coaches, disappointing seasons, and questionable moves, including an alleged scheme to lose games to improve draft picks—an accusation Haslam denies. Fans like Chris McNeil express that Watson’s presence and the organizational decisions around him symbolize a deeper disregard for the fans’ loyalty and patience. This sentiment is reflected in public protests and strong social media criticism, emphasizing a level of anger not seen in decades.

Head coach Todd Monken, meanwhile, has remained unfazed by the backlash, affirming that the fans do not decide who plays and that his focus is on fielding the best team possible. The Browns face an unusual situation in starting the season amid widespread fan opposition to their QB, a rare and challenging dynamic. The early schedule pits them against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Baker Mayfield—Watson’s predecessor—fueling hopes among fans for a dramatic showdown that might ultimately lead the Browns to reconsider their quarterback situation before the season’s home opener at the end of September.